Given the support at this important benchmark, this card should likely increase in value back toward the low-to-mid 100s
So how do I rate Shelob, Child of Ungoliant that low on this list

Use these protective sleeves on the following games: The Adventurers, Albion's Legacy, Arcadia Quest, Blood Bound, But Wait, There's More!, Castle Dice, Cave Troll, Circus Train, Dogs of War, Elder Sign, Eldritch, Eldritch Horror: Forsaken Lore, Five Fingered Severance, Forlorn: Hope, The Golden Wilderness, I, Spy, Infiltration, Kolejka, Level 7, Manhattan Project, Metropolis, Red November, Relic, Runewars, Show Business, Sid Meier's Civlization: The Board Game, Snow Tails, Space Cadets, Star Trek: Attack Wing, Star Wars: Armada, Star Wars: Imperial Assault, Talisman, The Witcher Adventure Game, Thrash-Car, Twilight Imperium, Um Reifenbreite, Venture Forth, Warhammer 40,000 Conquest, World of Warcraft: The Adventure Game, World of Warcraft: The Board Game, XCOM: The Board Game, and Zombicide Strong welds make for durable sleeves Sized for board game cards Clear, frosted panels Thick 4 mil polypropylene Designed for board game cards: Up to 41mm x 63mm Products You May Like BCW Regular Snap Card Holder $1.19 Sale Price: $0.89 BCW Interlocking Card Frame $36.99 Sale Price: $27.69 BCW Board Game Sleeves -- 56Mm X 87Mm $2.49 Sale Price: $1.89 Product is out of stock Humonhous Hoard Semi Rigid Card Holders Size 9 -- 12 x 16 $22.00 Sale Price: $19.79

Jack O Lantern merely redoes the roll